Renee here's what is in Las Animas County Marriages. I'll look in Holy Trinity next. However I still think he's one and the same
(First and second marriages). Give me a little time and I'll see if I find more.
Mares, Jesus ~~ Romero Beneranda 07 Feb 1887 Las Animas County License # unk
Mares, Jesus ~~ Garcia, Antonio (should be Antonia) 17 Dec 1916 Las Animas County #1941